In the case of regulation of fluids and gasses in industries, the choice of valve type is very important. Gate valves and ball valves are two of the most popular types of valves, both having their own strengths and uses.
It will be important to have an understanding of the differences between these two types in order to make sound decisions in different industrial applications. This article will look at the major differences between gate valves and ball valves as explained by top ball valve manufacturers.
Understanding Gate Valves
Gate valves are designed to open and close by lifting a gate out of the path of the fluid that is to be controlled. These valves are normally applied where there is need to have straight line flow of the fluid and where there is little or no need to control the flow of the fluid.
When the valve is fully open, the gate is fully withdrawn from the flow area, leaving only the valve body to create a minimum pressure drop across the full bore. This characteristic makes
gate valves most suitable for use in applications where the valve is required to open and close only occasionally, because the gate and seat are easily damaged when the valve is used for throttling purposes.
The gate valves are widely applied in the systems where the flow must be fully open or fully closed, for example, in the water treatment stations, in oil and gas systems, and in chemical industries. It is possible to achieve a very tight closure when the flanges are closed which is important in applications where leakage cannot be tolerated.
However, one of the main disadvantages of gate valves is that they are slow in operation since it takes several turns of the hand wheel to turn the gate from the open to closed position. This slow operation may be a disadvantage when there is a need to shut it off quickly, thus making gate valves less appropriate for use in cases where quick action is required in an emergency.
Exploring Ball Valves
Ball valves, on the other hand, are characterized by a different approach to the regulation of the flow of the medium. These valves employ a spherical ball with a hole passing through its middle that is in line with the pipeline when the valve is on.
A quarter turn of the valve handle turns the ball in a way that it opens or closes the passage of the fluid. This design makes ball valves capable of giving a good seal and also enables them to rotate up to 90 degrees, which makes them suitable for use in applications that require fast shutting off.
These valves have been designed to be very flexible by the ball valve manufacturers in that they can work under very high temperatures, pressures and with different types of fluids. They are widely applied in oil and gas, water supply, and HVAC systems and equipment. Another benefit of the ball valves is the fact that they are very sturdy and do not require frequent maintenance since the ball surface is very smooth.
Also, ball valves can be applied for on/off and modulating service, but the first one is more typical because the ball valve can give a tight shut-off when it is in the closed position. The general use of ball valves is attributed to their flexibility and durability in most industrial processes that require smooth operations and safety.
Gate Valve vs. Ball Valve
Comparing gate valves and ball valves, some peculiarities appear that can define the usage of one or another valve type. The most notable difference lies in the operation: gate valves take several turns to operate while opening or closing and on the other hand, ball valves only need a quarter turn to operate.
This makes ball valves more preferable for use where frequent operation is required. The high speed and non-sophisticated operation offered by ball valves are very essential in situations where there is need to act fast such as in cases where there is an emergency shut off.
The other major difference is in their sealing capacity. Both types of valves have a very good shutoff, but the ball valve has a better shutoff because of the design of the valve. The spherical ball in a ball valve makes sure that the sealing surfaces are equally compressed so as to minimize the chance of leakage even under high pressure.
On the other hand, gate valves are also quite useful, although the sealing surfaces may deteriorate after some time of usage, especially where the valve is frequently opened or closed, or used for throttling purposes. This makes ball valves more suitable in high pressure where tight shut off is important than gate valves.
Applications and Considerations
It is always advisable to compare between a gate valve and a ball valve depending on the needs of the place that needs the valve. Gate valves are used most commonly in large diameter pipelines where the flow of the fluid has to be either fully open or closed and where the pressure drop has to be kept to the minimum.
Their design enables them to have a straight flow path when fully opened and are suitable for use in main water lines, chemical plants and power plants.
On the other hand, ball valves are used in situations where tight shut off, high strength and low leakage, and non corrosive nature is desirable. These valves are used in applications where the valve has to open and close frequently; for example in the oil and gas industry, water supply networks, and food and beverage industries.
Ball valves are versatile and easy to operate and therefore are used in many industries. Also, ball valves are chosen in the places where the space is a concern since its dimensions are smaller than those of the gate valves.
Conclusion
When it comes to deciding between a gate valve and a ball valve, it is all about the requirements of the particular application. Gate valves are suitable for situations where pressure drop is undesirable and the valve is not expected to open and close frequently, while ball valves are well suited for situations where the valve must open and close rapidly, be very strong and provide a tight seal.
From the above analysis of the characteristics of each valve type, and by liaising with reputable ball valve manufacturers, it is possible for system designers and operators to make the right choices that will improve the performance and reliability of the system.
For industrial applications or for more specific uses, the selection of the right valve is critical in order to obtain the desired flow and performance. The advice from experienced ball valve manufacturers can be very useful in making the right decision and guarantee that the selected valve is suitable for the intended operation.
More Read About:
